language

HUATAO GROUP
News & Events

We Help Customers To Meet The Great Challenges Of Our Time.

VIEW PRODUCTS
scroll down

Back to Overview

How Do You Select the Right Hardness for a Suction Couch Roll Cover?

Nov 17,2026

How Do You Select the Right Hardness for a Suction Couch Roll Cover?

Selecting the right cover hardness for a suction couch roll is an important part of paper-machine engineering and maintenance. The cover must match the roll's forming-section duty, operating speed, vacuum conditions, mechanical loading, forming-fabric interaction, and service environment.

However, hardness selection is often complicated by the use of different measurement scales. Some purchasing specifications refer to Shore A, while others use P&J (Pusey and Jones). These values are not interchangeable.

P&J measures the indentation of a specified indenter into a rubber-covered roller under controlled conditions. Its numerical direction is inverse: a lower P&J value represents a harder cover, while a higher value represents a softer cover.

For paper mills purchasing replacement suction couch rolls or covers, the correct approach is to evaluate the entire application rather than select a number from a generic chart.

1. What Is P&J Hardness and Why Does It Matter?

P&J is a measurement system developed for assessing the apparent hardness of rubber-covered rollers.

The Pusey and Jones instrument measures indentation under a defined test load. The result is expressed as an indentation value rather than the same type of reading obtained using a Shore A durometer.

ISO 48-8:2018 provides the relevant method for determining the apparent hardness of vulcanized or thermoplastic rubber-covered rollers.

The distinction matters because two suppliers may quote hardness using different measurement systems. If the buyer does not identify the required scale, the resulting quotation and inspection records may not be directly comparable.

Important purchasing rules

Specify P&J or Shore A explicitly.

Never write only a numerical hardness value.

Identify the nominal value and tolerance.

Specify the test method and conditions.

Require a documented inspection result.

Verify any conversion using an agreed method.

A general conversion chart may be useful for preliminary discussion, but it should not replace an application-specific specification.

2. Which Factors Determine the Correct Suction Couch Roll Hardness?

The first step is to understand the roll's exact function.

A suction couch roll operates in the forming section, where the forming fabric transports the developing sheet and water is removed through vacuum-assisted drainage.

Its cover requirements should be assessed in relation to the entire forming system.

Machine operating speed

Provide normal and maximum machine speed, roll diameter, and any planned production-speed increase.

Rotational speed influences the mechanical demands on the roll assembly and can affect vibration, dynamic balance, cover deformation, and bonding requirements.

Vacuum and drainage conditions

Provide operating vacuum, suction-zone configuration, suction-hole pattern, suction-box information, and effective suction width.

The cover should be considered together with the suction structure and forming fabric. A hardness change cannot independently correct a poorly functioning vacuum system.

Forming-fabric interaction

The forming fabric is an important part of the application. Its construction, condition, tension, and contact with the roll should be considered when reviewing cover properties.

The buyer should also describe any known wear patterns, fabric damage, sheet instability, or uneven drainage.

Mechanical loading

Provide available load information, support arrangements, roll deflection criteria, and vibration records.

An excessively soft cover may deform more than intended under certain operating conditions. An excessively hard cover may produce an unsuitable contact response in some applications. These possibilities must be assessed against the actual compound and machine design.

Environmental exposure

Water, process chemicals, cleaning agents, temperature, and contamination may influence cover ageing and material compatibility.

3. How Should Rubber and Polyurethane Covers Be Compared?

Hardness alone cannot determine the best cover material.

Different formulations may exhibit different mechanical and chemical properties even when their measured P&J values are similar.

Rubber cover considerations

Rubber cover evaluation may include:

Elastic resilience.

Tear strength.

Abrasion resistance.

Hysteresis and heat generation.

Resistance to water and cleaning chemicals.

Bonding strength.

Surface finishing and maintenance requirements.

Polyurethane cover considerations

Polyurethane cover evaluation may include:

Abrasion resistance.

Mechanical strength.

Elastic recovery.

Hydrolysis resistance.

Chemical compatibility.

Temperature limitations.

Bonding and finishing requirements.

The correct choice depends on the specific application. A material should not be selected simply because it is described as harder, tougher, or more wear-resistant.

 

4. How Should a Paper Mill Verify the Selected Hardness?

A reliable selection process starts with documentation and ends with measurable acceptance criteria.

Review the original specification

Collect the OEM drawing, original cover material, nominal hardness, test reports, and maintenance records.

If the existing cover has performed satisfactorily, its original specification can provide a useful baseline. However, changes in machine speed, paper grade, vacuum conditions, and forming-fabric design should be considered.

Inspect the old cover

Record cracks, wear, surface deterioration, profile changes, uneven contact, and possible delamination.

Remember that the measured hardness of an aged cover may differ from its original manufactured condition.

Confirm the proposed material and hardness

Ask the supplier to identify the proposed compound, hardness scale, nominal value, tolerance, and application rationale.

The supplier should explain why the proposed specification is suitable for the intended roll position.

Define testing and acceptance

Specify the applicable P&J method, test temperature, cover thickness, number of readings, measurement locations, and acceptance limits.

Request a hardness inspection report before shipment. Keep the report with the roll's technical and maintenance records.

5. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. What is the ideal P&J hardness for a suction couch roll?

There is no universal ideal value. The correct hardness depends on the roll's application, material formulation, operating speed, mechanical loading, vacuum conditions, forming-fabric interaction, and OEM requirements. A technical review should establish the appropriate target for the actual machine.

Q2. Is P&J hardness the same as Shore A?

No. Shore A and P&J use different measurement methods. Shore A uses a durometer, while P&J measures indentation on a rubber-covered roller. The numerical values cannot be directly substituted without an agreed and verified comparison method.

Q3. Why does P&J hardness use an inverse scale?

P&J expresses indentation rather than conventional hardness degrees. A harder material produces less indentation and therefore a lower P&J reading. A softer material produces greater indentation and a higher reading.

Q4. Can a harder cover improve roll service life?

Not necessarily. Service life depends on the compound, abrasion, loading, temperature, water and chemical exposure, surface condition, and maintenance. A harder cover may be unsuitable if it does not meet the required contact and mechanical behavior.

Q5. Can a softer cover improve water removal?

Not automatically. Water removal depends on vacuum, forming fabric, suction-hole design, sheet characteristics, machine speed, and the overall forming-section configuration. Cover hardness should not be treated as an independent drainage-control variable.

Q6. Should I change hardness when replacing an old suction couch roll?

Not without reviewing the reason for replacement. If the old cover has performed well, its original specification provides a useful reference. If there are wear, vibration, drainage, or surface problems, investigate the root cause before changing hardness.

Q7. How do I specify hardness tolerance?

State the nominal P&J value, permitted deviation, applicable test method, temperature, and measurement locations. Agree on the inspection procedure before manufacturing so the supplier and buyer use the same acceptance criteria.

Q8. Can I compare two cover suppliers using their quoted hardness alone?

No. Compare material formulation, hardness scale, resilience, abrasion resistance, chemical compatibility, cover thickness, surface finish, bonding, and inspection requirements. Two covers with similar hardness values may have different performance characteristics.

Q9. Does operating temperature influence hardness measurements?

Yes. Elastomer properties and measured hardness can be influenced by temperature. The test temperature should be controlled and documented so that measurements can be compared consistently.

Q10. What information is required for a replacement-cover quotation?

Provide the roll drawing, diameter, face length, machine position, speed range, vacuum conditions, forming-fabric details, existing material, nominal hardness, wear condition, and inspection requirements. Identify missing data clearly.

Conclusion

The correct hardness for a suction couch roll cover is an application-specific engineering decision. P&J and Shore A should be treated as separate measurement systems, while material properties, vacuum-assisted dewatering, forming-fabric interaction, speed, mechanical loading, and environmental exposure must be evaluated together.

A complete specification, suitable material selection, and consistent hardness inspection provide a sound basis for replacement procurement.

Related Products and Technical Resources

PAPER MACHINE ROLL

SUCTION PRESS ROLL

HUATAO INDUSTRIAL ROLLS

ABOUT HUATAO

HUATAO TECHNICAL NEWS

 

Contact HUATAO

Tony Liu | International Department
Mobile / WhatsApp / WeChat: +86 13383112591
Email: sale08@huataogroup.com
Website: www.huataorolls.com

HUATAO welcomes customers worldwide to discuss custom industrial roll and paper-machine roll requirements. Send your drawings, material specifications, and operating data to begin a technical discussion.